By Jon Vanstone, chair Certass Trade Association.

Bad advice is surprisingly easy to ignore when it sounds ridiculous. The dangerous kind is the advice you have heard for 20 years, usually from somebody who, at the time, knew a great deal more than you did.

Advertisement Advertisement

It does not announce itself. It arrives wearing the authority of experience, which is exactly why it slips past unchallenged.

Every practical industry accumulates this kind of inherited knowledge, and glazing is full of it. Much of it is enormously valuable, the observations, shortcuts and pieces of judgement that never reach a technical manual yet save an experienced installer hours because somebody once showed them a better way.

The trouble is that good knowledge and outdated knowledge travel by the same route, so that nothing about how advice reaches you tells you whether it is still true.

Ventilation is a good example just now. The Certass technical team still meets explanations built on the old 30% rule, night latch positions, open fireplaces, extractor fans, coastal properties and busy roads.

These are rarely invented on the spot. More often, somebody genuinely believes they know the answer because, at some point, that was the answer, or at least part of it.

That is what makes such misconceptions so stubborn. They do not feel like misconceptions at all. They feel like experience, which is a far harder thing to argue with.

Construction is especially prone to this, because regulations change far more readily than habits do. A document is revised, guidance moves on, the reasoning develops, and yet nobody arrives on site the following Monday to wipe 20 years of knowledge from every head. The old rule keeps circulating because it is familiar, easy to remember and probably served people perfectly well for years.

There is nothing remotely foolish in that. It is simply how experience works. Faced with hundreds of decisions in a week, none of us returns to first principles each time. We recognise a situation we have seen before and apply what we learned last time, and without those shortcuts most businesses would grind to a halt by Wednesday afternoon.

So competence cannot mean never trusting your experience. It has to mean something harder and more useful, knowing when a piece of that experience has earned another look.

Background ventilation shows this, because it is easy to reduce the whole subject to a handful of remembered rules. Does this count as ventilation? Does that mean I can leave out a trickle vent? What if the customer lives on a main road? The pull is always towards the answer that has lived comfortably in your head for years.

Sometimes that answer will still be exactly right. Sometimes the circumstances will make it relevant without making it the whole story. And every so often the rule you are reaching for belongs to a version of the requirements that has quietly moved on without it.

This is why I have grown wary of the phrase “we’ve always done it this way”. Not because doing something for years makes it wrong, but because longevity is no evidence that the world around it has stood still. In a trade that has moved considerably on thermal performance, ventilation, product standards and Building Regulations, it would be remarkable if every scrap of 20-year-old knowledge had survived intact.

Schemes and technical bodies carry a responsibility here too. Telling an installer that something they have understood for years is now simply wrong is easy, and useless. Explaining what has changed, why, and what they should do instead is far more valuable.

If current guidance is to replace the old folklore, it has to be accessible enough to compete with the bloke who explained the 30% rule over a cup of tea 15 years ago, because that is the standard it is really up against.

The best installers I know are not the ones who claim to have every answer filed permanently away. They are comfortable enough in their experience to question it now and then. They know when something is genuinely straightforward, and when it would be wise to check.

None of that diminishes experience. If anything, it is one of the clearest signs of it.

After all, 20 years in any industry ought to teach you a great deal. One of those things ought to be that the industry never stands still.